I love muffins. They have this sort of nostalgic value for me. However, I’m not talking about just any old muffin. No, no, it’s a diner-style, extra-large with an overflowing muffin top. The flavors are bran, corn, or if I hit the jackpot, morning glory.
The kind you would imagine to discover at a little gem of a breakfast spot that has regulars who have been patrons for 30 years. At the kind of place where everyone is on a first-name basis, but you. A place with a grill top that serves hot muffins slathered in salty butter, grilled on each side to golden brown perfection. Yes. That’s my kind of muffin.
In an attempt to recreate my childhood memories, I set out to create the most perfect diner-style morning glory muffin. I just love how moist these are and how much flavor and texture is packed into them. The oversized jumbo muffin is really kind of fun, too!
Feel free to use 50/50 AP and Whole Wheat flour if you so desire. You could even swap it 100%. Whole wheat absolutely works in this recipe.
In this recipe, I call for a mixture of vegetable oil, applesauce and orange juice to get a total volume of 1 cup. This helps add moisture and flavor, however, if you’re in a pinch you could do all applesauce, all oil, or even melted butter or yogurt. All of these combinations would provide deliciously moist muffins. If you can keep the orange juice, it adds a nice brightness to the flavor.
Dark brown sugar.
Light brown will absolutely do if it’s what you have. If you don’t have brown sugar, but happen to have a dark liquid sweetener like molasses or maple syrup, you can make your own by adding the liquid to regular sugar slowly until desired darkness and texture is reached.
In any of my baked goods recipes that call for raisins, I ask you to reconstitute them with warm water. The reason is that the texture is so much more enjoyable when there’s some softness added back in. It doesn’t need to be perfect, but you want to see the raisins plump or swell up a bit. Just make sure to drain them so that you’re not inadvertently adding extra water to the batter.
If you have an orange, that would be a great replacement. Or you could do half and half. I really encourage you to keep this ingredient as it really enhances the flavor by adding brightness.
This ingredient can absolutely be omitted if there is a nut allergy or a preference. However, I highly encourage you to use pecans rather than substituting for some other nut. For example, I’ve tried to bake with chopped walnuts again and again, and it just adds too strong of a flavor and texture. I say stick with the pecans. They are tender and delicate, yet add a much-desired crunch.
This recipe is a simple batter that asks you to mix the wet ingredients and the dry ingredients separately, then incorporate the dry into the wet. Stir in the mix-ins and it’s done. I use my standing mixer, but you could mix by hand with a wooden spoon if need be.
I call for jumbo muffin tins in this recipe to create a nostalgic-size muffin. Any size will absolutely do.
My tip is just to fill to the top of each muffin well so that it rises up and over to create a classic golden muffin-top.