I originally created this recipe for my personal blog almost a year ago, but have continued to tweak it every time I’ve made it since. I’m excited to present to you my best version yet; the ultimate fudgy brownie with tahini swirl.
It’s funny, I used to be a boxed brownie girl all the way. What’s not to love? Chewy, fudgy, and honestly, just super easy-to-make. I never really thought to make them from scratch, and it took years after I went to culinary school for it to even dawn on me to do so. “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it”, they say and I wasn’t about to try… Until I did.
I suddenly found myself thinking, if I want to get closer to becoming a confident baker with a recipe box full of tried and trues, shouldn’t I start with the basics and go from there?
So suddenly, I took interest in brownie making. It’s funny, it’s not too hard to make a brownie, but there are about a million different ways to do it. I’ve seen so many variations that range vastly and it’s amazing how a brownie is always still, well, just a brownie.
If nothing else I hope it’s proof, and thus peace of mind to you, that brownies are pretty easy to make. Recipes and quantities vary greatly, but I have yet to try a homemade brownie that wasn’t delicious. One of my favorite things to bring to a dinner party is the makings for homemade brownie sundaes bar.
Everyone loves a classic brownie sundae, and who doesn’t love to create their own with their personal favorite yummies; homemade whipped cream, chopped walnuts, fudge and caramel sauce, and of course classic vanilla bean ice cream served over a piping hot, salty brownie. Pop it in the oven when everyone sits down for the meal, and when you’re ready for dessert you’ve got a real winner. Your dinner party contribution will suddenly become the best contribution.
This recipe is my favorite because it’s super simple, but calls for a few techniques that really amplify the finished product.
One technique is the double boiler. This is when you take a heat proof bowl, place it over the top of a small saucepan with water, and steam melt chocolate (and butter). This keeps everything from burning which can happen easily if done any other way. Anyone who wants to make something with chocolate should learn this method.
Another technique I call for is using a handheld mixer to mix the eggs and sugar. This helps give brownies a shiny crust that you get from a box. When you add the tahini swirl you do lose it a little, but it’s important for texture, too.
Salted Butter. If you don’t have this on hand, just add a pinch more salt to give it the salt this brownie needs.
Tahini. If you don’t love tahini, I understand. Feel free to use any nut or seed butter. You may not need confectioners sugar if you do use a substitution. It just depends on the bitterness of the variety you land on.
Pans & Cooking Times. I love this Chicago Metallic brownie pan. It’s a 9x12 so the brownies are a bit thinner and cooking time a bit faster, but the easy removable bottom and perfect cut insert makes life a total synch, especially when feeding a crowd. However, if you want thick brownies, definitely don’t go beyond an 8x8, or double the recipe.
Handheld mixer. I find a handheld the best for this recipe and I LOVE the KRUPS mixer I use in the photos above. It’s super sleek and efficient, and has silicone lined whisks that make it safe to use in any material bowl (even metal), and helps scrape the sides as you mix. I highly recommend!